Tuesday, January 25, 2005

The Maternal Lien: A Real World Solution to Abortion

Below, I make the trespass analogy to abortion, and then use necessity as a defense to that trespass. But there was on doctrine I mention: that a trespasser must still reimburse the owner for the damage caused by the trespass. If some similar doctrine were applied to abortion, it could seriously curb the abortion rate in this country, while possibly curing problems of senior citizen care.

I propose the following; a Maternal Lien. Upon a child reaching majority, every natural mother would have a right from their natural child a certain amount of money, a debt arising purely from gestation of that person as a child. For example, (1) In 1984, mother bears and delivers child, (2) In 2005, child reaches majority, (3) Child now owes mother $20,000, accruing at 4%; child now has to pay mother approximately $83.00 a month for forty years. Thus a mother would not have an abortion out of pure greed, while a fetus would have a definite, substantive basis for his "right to life".

Q: Isn’t it a little heartless for a mother to demand money from her child?

A: Perhaps. Yet it’s also heartless for a mother to suck a baby’s brains out or drown it in salt water before it has a chance to live. Besides, it is a common assertion that children have the duty to provide for their parents. This law would simply codify that principle

Q: Wouldn’t that encourage mothers to have tons of children, regardless of how they’re reared, and for those children to do the same, resulting in some sort of motherhood ponzi racket?

A: Thus it is important to make the amount just right. Too much would encourage prolific, irresponsible breeding. Too little would not be much incentive or reimburse the mother.

Q: What about the father?

A: Remember, we are reimbursing for gestation only, i.e. not aborting the pregnancy. Also, reimbursement to men can conceive literally thousands of children; women only a few, thus causing the ponzi racket problem. And besides, this will encourage male fidelity: If they are to enjoy the benefits of having children, they are going to need to live with their mate.

Q: The kind of women who get unwanted pregnancies are not the kind of women who think in terms of the time value of money. They’re not going to wait 21 years for a measly $80 to dribble in. What’s the incentive to forego the abortion now for money later.

A: Discounting. Suppose a mother has the right an annuity of $960.00 per year in 21 years. A bank does some financial calculations and determines the present value of that right is $10500.00. They offer the woman $9,000.00 for their right in her maternal lien. She accepts and forgoes the abortion. The woman gets instant gratification, while the bank gets a great cashflow stream.

Think it could work? Let me know

7 Comments:

At 4:57 AM, Blogger Tan said...

I am no economist but me crazy Malaysian thinks it might just work. But I don't know what if taking care of the child costs more than what she will get then she might think the abortion is better but are stupid anough to get pregnant by some loser and not realise the long-term consequneces I am sure they won't be able to resist the sort-term gratification of $9000.
Still what if they child grows up to be some loser just like their dads and moms and can't pay up. No doubt this will be a minority but still...yeah I guess it will be an incentive for the mom to bring the child up0 properly.
Sad isn't it that what is suppose to be a natural relationship full of love between a mother and child needs a good dose of money to happen.

 
At 6:02 AM, Blogger Daniel James Devine said...

I've posted some thoughts on this idea at www.globelens.com

 
At 1:46 AM, Blogger Tan said...

thinking about what you said about maternal lien reminded of an old idea about illustrating fallacy of the pro-choice's argument.
Ths idea include getting a bunch of vets to break into a zoo and perform an abortion on an endangered animal. Preferably a well-publicised gestation and in a state where trespassing laws are lenient. And hopefully a massive well-publicised court case will ensue. Then they will use every argument pro-choice people use life the human foetus is not human and all that.
I think this is better than murdering abortion providers which not only lose you supporters but give a chance to the MSM to make pro-lifers look bad.
What say you of this idea?

 
At 1:54 PM, Blogger BnonB said...

Parenting requires a much larger commitment than a future promise of money. Plus, pregnancy, child rearing and abortion are all intensely personal experiences and can't/shouldn't be legislated.

 
At 3:34 PM, Blogger faith said...

Hi ##NAME##, while looking for info on hyip fraud, I saw your blog ##TITLE##. A lot of people got excited by it. Those may be the same folks who get excited about the idea of ending the day with $150 for every $100 they "spend" in a HYIP. In time they will have to face up to having lost their butts in a scam, fraud, or ponzi scheme. Better to have the hyip fraud information upfront like in the ##LINK##. You don't have to buy the ebook & membership for $47 to avoid losing - or just don't play - until you know how the pros who wrote it make their money - and yours too!

 
At 10:47 AM, Blogger charity said...

Hi ##NAME##, while looking for info on hyip scams, I saw your blog ##TITLE##. A lot of people got excited by it. Those may be the same folks who get excited about the idea of ending the day with $150 for every $100 they "spend" in a HYIP. In time they will have to face up to having lost their butts in a scam, fraud, or ponzi scheme. Better to have the hyip scams information upfront like in the ##LINK##. You don't have to buy the ebook & membership for $47 to avoid losing - or just don't play - until you know how the pros who wrote it make their money - and yours too!

 
At 1:45 PM, Blogger Abby said...

The child should not have to pay for the parents mistake.There are so many options that people don't think of , they just jump to the conclusion of abortion.The mother could find a couple who is unable to get pregnant and they could pay her and the mother gets her money and the child gets a chance at life.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home